System Status: Checking...
Core:
SQL
NoSQL
RT
Batch
Analysis:
Brand
Camel
Cat
Clarity
Avail
Common
Mem
Rhyme
SEO
SEO-
Sent
Syll
TLD
Tone
TM
Whois
Rank

Appraisal Process

Back to all topics

What is a consensus appraisal?

A consensus appraisal runs five independent valuations of your domain, drops the highest and the lowest, and converges the middle three into one range. You get the same report as a standard appraisal - value range, strengths, weaknesses, market analysis, comparable sales - but the number behind it is the agreement of five opinions instead of one.

Why it exists

AI valuations, like human ones, vary between sittings. We measured this on more than 1,200 domains, appraising each five times: the typical gap between a domain's highest and lowest single valuation was 29%, one domain in three exceeded 50%, and on roughly one domain in five, at least one of the five runs spiked above 1.5x the median opinion. A single appraisal is a sample from that spread; a consensus is the center of it.

Why five opinions

  • Five is the smallest panel where you can discard both extremes and still average a majority (three).
  • Since about one run in five spikes optimistic, dropping the highest and lowest guarantees a lone outlier - high or low - never touches your result.
  • The result is remarkably stable: in our measurements, replacing any single opinion typically shifts the consensus by 0% (it moves only when two or more opinions genuinely disagree). Single opinions swing by a third; the consensus barely notices any one of them.
  • More than five runs adds cost faster than it adds stability.

How to run one

  • New appraisal: tick the "Consensus appraisal" toggle on your dashboard - 9 credits.
  • Upgrade an existing appraisal: use the "Upgrade to Consensus" button on the appraisal page - 6 credits. Your current appraisal counts as one of the five opinions and is archived. Note the pricing is deliberately fair: appraise once (3) then upgrade (6) costs exactly the same as consensus from the start (9), so no ordering is ever the wrong choice.
  • Batch: tick "Run as consensus batch" on the batch page - 6 credits per domain. Built for portfolios and your best names.
  • Anonymous reports: every $19.99 guest report has always been a consensus of five.

Fair-billing guarantee

If fewer than three opinions complete (rare service degradation), we deliver a standard single-run appraisal and charge the standard rate - never the consensus rate. Consensus results are labeled with a "Consensus of 5" badge on the appraisal page.

Consensus is the same method behind our published research, including our ten-year study of the industry's largest reported sales.

12 views 1 helpful

We use cookies to enhance your experience and analyze our website traffic. Learn more